Joe Waldis a 70-year-old Swiss tourist went fishing this week off the British Isles and caught himself a 1,056-lb. shark(!). We imagine he was probably pretty psyched.

When he got back to land, killed it, weighed it, and realized it was the largest fish ever caught by rod, he was definitely psyched. Predictably though, some people are complaining about the catch and it's not namby-pamby treehuggers. Some of Waldis's fellow fishermen say he should have thrown the beast back.

"It is regrettable that such a magnificent fish had to be taken to shore to be weighed to verify a record," said Richard Peirce, chairman of the Shark Trust.

Would you have thrown back the biggest fish EVER?

Editors' note: in an earlier version of this story we incorrectly stated Joe Waldis was from Scotland.