Brett Smiley is a freelance writer and Asylum's Funfetti correspondent. When I first laid my eyes on a McDonald's holiday pie (yesterday), I fell in love. But it was just a picture. So, with my belly yearning for Funfetti magic, I set out to find where I might locate this wondrous holiday pie.
I started with a grassroots approach. I called 15 McDonald's restaurants in the greater New York City area. "Huh?" they replied. "We have apple pies."
But I didn't want an apple pie; I wanted a caloric-disaster holiday pie, which looked like a combination of a Funfetti cake and a custard doughnut in the shape of a hot pocket.
With hunger as my guide, I called McDonald's customer service line.
A representative told me 85 percent of McDonald's restaurants are
franchises that decide individually whether to stock the holiday pie, so she has no way of locating the rare delicacy.
My quest now took me back to the Internet, where Yelp.com users ridiculed a like-minded pie hunter with cruel and misguided comments like "It looks like a piece of ashy oxidized turd stuffed with baby vomit." I sought guidance on Yahoo! Answers, where users in Mayfield, Ohio; Hardinsburg, Ky.; and Milan, Mich., claimed local McDonald's stocked the pies. I even found a Facebook group that professed its love for the pies.
But still I was denied the pie I craved, or any kind of resource to find them.
I turned next to a blogger named Mr. Inconspicuous, the author of an unflattering review of the pies who has unintentionally become an authority on the mysterious baked good. He pointed me to a greater Washington, D.C., area McDonald's. So I hit the phones again. "Huh?" they asked.
One restaurant in Arlington, Va., used to have them. The employee sensed my desperation. She offered an apple pie.
All signs led me to the sad realization that the holiday pie is a seasonal item, stocked only by a brilliant few franchise owners located mostly in the Midwest and South. But a lucky few of you out there may still be able to capture one of these pies.
If you can locate one, enjoy it first. And then let us know where you found out so we may live vicariously through you.
Crazy Legs Conti: The Time I Tried a 36-hour Fruit Punch Diet


























St. Louis Sports Bar Gives Man Receipt Criticizing His Child
'Undercover Boss': Top 4 Moments From Season 4 [VIDEO]
Las Vegas Court Officials Accused Of Covering Up Sex Assault [VIDEO]
Groomers Lose Dog, Claim Not Responsible
Male Judge Sets Dress Code For Female Lawyers And Sparks Uproar
'Lone Ranger' Star Johnny Depp Opens Up About Split From Vanessa Paradis
The Story Behind Shapewear: From Girdles to Spanx
'Grease' Cast: Where Are They Now?
Careless Chinese Baggage Handler Really Throws Himself Into His Work
Microsoft E3 2013 Xbox liveblog!







Comments:
Add a comment
Thursday 31 December
By abrlcklnthewall
Yeah, there was one in Alexandria on Route 7 that had them for a minute. The sprinkles were of http://www.sugarcraft.com/catalog/flowers/nonpareils.jpg that variety. The custard filling was ok... nothing truly amazing, even under influences. Pumpkin pies are still the top dog when it comes to seasonal pies.
Reply
Sunday 03 January
By Kdub
They also had them at the Mcd's on Rte 1 Crystal city. I first ran across these delicious pies in Florida many years ago and look forward to each X-mas season. all Mcdonalds should carry them. They are a Sugar cookie crust with spinkles and custard filling, what other fast food desert can be so good (taste) yet so bad (Heart)... I tell all my friends about this pie, and they look at me like I'm nuts! Sweet deliciousness...
Sunday 03 January
By pjkarns
Yes, I work at a McDoanld's in Mid-Ohio and we had the Holiday pie for 2 weeks before and half a week after Christmas. We are now back to Cherry and Apple. I thought it was very good. The inside was a warm custard filling and the sprinkles added enough sugar to make it all nice and sweet tasting.
Sunday 03 January
By Ryan Mullins
We have them in Vienna IL.
Sunday 03 January
By ANGELA
they have them all over upstate new york
Sunday 03 January
By carol
we had them here in Crawforsvile Indiana, They were yummy! I had 4 of them and yes they were as rich as they sound and filled with custard to the brim wish I had gotten more ! thank you Mc Donalds for the yummy treat!
Sunday 03 January
By HEather
DELICIOUS!!!!!!!!! They have them all over in Michigan!!!
Sunday 03 January
By misty plank
i am actually a manager at mcdonalds and while none of our mcdonalds carry the holiday pie i have tried one and they are delicious. there is a mcdonalds close to me in white pigeon michigan and they do carry them around christmas time. if you really want to try one i suggest next year around xmas you take a road trip. it will be worth it.
Sunday 03 January
By Ashley
Almost all Michigan stores had them, but indeed they are only a sesonal pie, yes they are delicious, however they only stocked them for about 3 weeks, and then no one could get them anymore. Just enough time for everyone to say oohh these are really good and then they are gone.
Sunday 03 January
By rbnwstrck
why anyone desperately wants to eat a chunk of processed sugary crap is beyond me. Plz, do yourself a favor and eat an apple.
Sunday 03 January
By John
A bigger mystery is what is really in the meat filler that comes from a company called "Beef Products". Look it up, there are news articles. you won't want to eat it.
Sunday 03 January
By nikki
i work at mcdonalds in coraopolis pa and we have them they arnt that great tho/........
Sunday 03 January
By Andrew
I work at a McDonalds in Chippewa Pennsylvania. We had them for the week of Christmas, sold out, and our distribution center has no more. Odds are, theyre gone. Better luck next year to try a delicious pie
Sunday 03 January
By mony
i recently came from deltona florida where i came across the holiday pies. i thought they were pretty good, i ordered six. when i came back to ny nobody ever heard of them but im glad i got to experience the holiday pie.
Monday 04 January
By Chef Alfred Schrader
This makes me a bit sad. People searching for a "thing" filled with modified food starch goo that comes off a machine.
Monday 04 January
By Catherine
I want a McD's Fried Apple/Cherry Pie. The only place I could find the Apple version was at the McD's inside of McCormick Place in Chicago.
Monday 15 February
By David
They are at the McCdonalds in morgantown, PA 19520
Wednesday 03 February
By pie lover
I found a place in Lancaster, Pa that has them it's a McDonald's on Lincoln Highway going towards a bunch of shopping outlets.
Thursday 23 December
By Evan
I had a holiday pie early Friday morning. I live in Washington, D.C. and I was headed home for my winter break to my home on Long Island. I had had another holiday pie the previous December near the White House, but this was the McDonald's outside the Verizon Centre. I had it along with a bacon, egg, and cheese McGriddle, hash brown, and sweet tea. Honestly, I have no idea what the holiday pie actually is, or even if it is good, it is just so indiscribable you have to have it. The apple pie is much better than the Holiday pie, but this warm custardy center encapsulated by Funfetti is just so crazy it's a must try. There are also cherry and chocolate pies as special pies. The chocolate pie is legit hot fudge in the apple pie crust. It's stupid good. It's kind of like the Shamrock Shakes, you can't get them everywhere, but when you do it's pretty good. I don't know why it's only the Beltway and Midwest, holiday pie is a must try!!
The other thing that's weird is the whole mustard thing. On Long Island we don't do mustard. Never, it's ketchup and maybe mayo, mustard is for hot dogs. But in WAshington mustard infiltrates the burger population and not for the better. McDonald's needs to unify it's mustard policy and get rid of it. But I'm sure a lot of people like it. I don't.
Thursday 31 December
By FormerMcDonaldan
Looks like it might be a regular custard pie. Some one i worked with said they stopped doing them years ago. McDonalds has a lot of secret sh*t they don't release or have only released once in a while. Like the mint-chocolate shrek shake,the mcRib, or the mango rasberry shake that never made it past our selve and then ended up in the trash. Kind sucks, but good luck!
Reply