Millions of dog owners talk to, converse with or just babble at their four-legged friends every day. And despite the fact that man's best friend doesn't talk back, most pet owners seem to believe they're having some kind of impact when they hold imagined conversations with their canine friends. But what do dogs really think of the verbal barrage? Do they think people are nuts? If so, owners with a unique voice for their pets -- usually a couple octaves higher -- might be a special kind of crazy. Or maybe not.
We were curious, so we asked a couple of pet experts just what our mutts make of our monologues.
"It's all about association," says Dr. James Serpell, director of the Center for the Interaction of Animals and Society at the University of Pennsylvania. "They might even find that reassuring. A conversational tone is associated with good things, and so dogs wouldn't be confused or upset by a prolonged discourse."
But, just because your dog reacts to the sound of your voice doesn't mean you should get carried away and imagine more people-like behaviors to dogs. "If you're humanizing and applying human behaviors to a dog, it's just not accurate," says Rachel Friedman, a professional trainer and behavioral consultant based in Cleveland, Ohio. "People often tell me, 'My dog is jealous', but dogs don't experience that."
Regardless of what dogs experience or perceive, most Americans treat dogs as part of the family. "Survey figures show that 70-80 percent of households with dogs think of them as family members," says Dr. Serpell. "The dog is a member of the family and part of the social group." And although they don't talk back to us, or speak our language per se, they do communicate with us.
"People talk to their dogs because they respond," says Dr. Serpell. "They alter their attention state. They will look at you, as if they attempt to grasp what you're saying, and they are giving positive feedback in that sense. You're not talking to the sofa -- you're talking to something."
But try as dogs might to understand, much of what people say may be falling on floppy, deaf ears.
"In my experience, people talk to their dogs way too much," says Friedman. "I think people tend to just babble at their pets, and they don't necessarily understand; people may babble to keep the animal focused, but you may be talking way more than they understand."
So maybe that's how dog became man's best friend -- because they listen no matter what, and don't tell us how ridiculous we sound.


























St. Louis Sports Bar Gives Man Receipt Criticizing His Child
'Undercover Boss': Top 4 Moments From Season 4 [VIDEO]
Las Vegas Court Officials Accused Of Covering Up Sex Assault [VIDEO]
Xbox One-80: Microsoft reverses Xbox One DRM features
Groomers Lose Dog, Claim Not Responsible
Male Judge Sets Dress Code For Female Lawyers And Sparks Uproar
'Lone Ranger' Star Johnny Depp Opens Up About Split From Vanessa Paradis
The Story Behind Shapewear: From Girdles to Spanx
'Grease' Cast: Where Are They Now?
Careless Chinese Baggage Handler Really Throws Himself Into His Work







Comments:
Add a comment
Friday 19 March
By Vanessa
"People often tell me, 'My dog is jealous', but dogs don't experience that."
Uh, didn't they just come out with a study that proves this statement wrong???
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2008/12/081208-dogs-envy.html
I don't think these so-called experts even know what they are babbling about.
Reply
Sunday 04 April
By Kay
Without even looking at the link you posted, I can tell you for certain, this was something that "came out" quite a while ago.
I have heard of this "expert" and although she may be partially correct in some her babbling, it has been well established by ethologists that, at least, some, 'mammals', dogs included, do experience emotions similar to that of our own, such as "jealousy".
However, I tend to agree that when people make statements like " My dog, "Charlie", thinks he is a cat.", they may be taking it a bit too far. I seriously doubt any dog "thinks" he/she is a cat, any more than you or I think we are butterflies.
I have been training animals for almost 30 years. And I am growing very tired of all the egos flapping their mouths about their "expert" opinions and how "right" they are and how everyone else is so "wrong". Especially in the dog training area.
I suppose, in past training experience, the need for "cut throat", back stabbing competitive actions never had presented all of the ugliness of the profession. Everyone needed to work together for the "whole" in order to succeed. What an eye opener for me! These people are ruthless.
Blah, blah, anyway, in a nutshell, the "so called experts" are just that, and most of them really don't know what they are talking about. They have just read something from a book and now, call themselves a dog training expert.
Sunday 02 May
By Deborah
Oh yes, dogs DO experience jealousy!
Sunday 02 May
By kathy
Dogs and cats most certainly do understand some of what you say to them im a groomer and although body language and tone of voice has something to do with it,they do understand words like sit down lay down give me your paw.to many times i have been surprised by talking to dogs i was grooming and they did what i asked them to with out hand gestures or body movement of any kind.as far as extensive conversation im not sure if they listen for key words or if they understand everything you say but they are definitely listening.and yes they get jealous and depressed with the loss of a loved one.
Reply
Sunday 02 May
By ED
When i am getting ready to go run errands, my dog knows and is acting anxious because he always goes with me. But, the other day i was totally surprised when i got ready to go, and he was jumping all over in excitment about going, I told him, "you can't go with me right now, you have to wait" at that point his tail went between his legs and he burrowed under the pillow as i went out the door. He understood he was not going. I felt so bad i almost took him with me..lol.. i believe dogs know certain words therefore, they have a degree of understanding.
Reply
Wednesday 09 November
By Fabio Carli
I am the owner of a 10 year old Doberman and I can tell you: he "does" understand a lot when talking to him without association to anything. You ask him something [he must be aware of] and he would execute. He wouldn't do it only if he doesn't want to do it. He can say: "I want" and "I love mama", when he is in good spirit it is pretty understandable. it does take a lot of training though. When you say a word that he doesn't know he look at you, you explain it to him a few time and in a short while he gets it and execute. So the "so called experts" should do some more home work or spend more time with dogs.
Reply