Sharks get all the love. They have their own week on the Discovery Channel, there are scads of scary movies about them and their attributes are even applied on a human scale to members of society engaged in professions like card-playing and the law.So, we got to wondering: Are sharks really all they're cracked up to be? Could there be an even more fearsome predator among us? How, for instance, do sharks stack up -- in terms of deadliness and danger to humans in the U.S. -- to alligators?
Shark attacks in the U.S. have been on the decline for a decade. Meanwhile, in Florida -- and let's be realistic, when you're talking about U.S. alligator attacks, they're happening in Florida -- alligator attacks tripled in recent years, from an annual average of five from 1948 to 1986 to an average of 14 between 1986 to 2005.
Keep reading to find out which creature is deadlier.
The Attacks
In February, a 38-year-old man in Stuart, Fla., was killed by sharks, which swarmed around him while he was kiteboarding about a quarter-mile offshore. On Aug. 2, a Pennsylvania woman visiting Mickler's Landing had her arm shredded by a shark while standing in chest-deep water.
In between, about 20 other people were attacked by sharks in U.S. waters this year. In 2001, there were 50 incidents, resulting in three fatalities. That number has steadily dropped for the last 10 years (though it spiked back to 50 in 2007); in 2009, 28 people were bitten in U.S. waters, but no one died.
There have been roughly a dozen alligator attacks to date in 2010. Last year, there were 19, the same number recorded in 2007 and 2008. (Coincidence? Or is someone at the Florida Department of Gator Bites and Other Random Statistics just getting lazy and jotting down the same number every year?)In July, an alligator created a new Captain Hook, chomping off the left hand of an 18-year-old male in Fort Myers as he swam in a creek. The gator pulled him underwater; the teen flailed away with his remaining good arm until the critter let go and swam away (with the hand, which was found in the gator's stomach when it was captured later that day).
Another Florida teen was attacked by a 12-foot gator in June while swimming in a canal near Okeechobee. He managed to get away after poking the gator in the eye, but noticed as he swam to shore that his left arm was missing.
Also in June, an alligator wrestler at a theme park in New Port Richey was attacked during a show, a scene most people in the crowd thought was part of the performance. (Side note: The gator was corralled and captured by Asylum's favorite animal trapper, Vernon Yates).
On June 23, a man snorkeling in a Marion County canal was bitten multiple times and sustained a broken jaw in a gator attack.
And in May, a 35-year-old Kissimmee man training for a triathlon was attacked; he has since announced plans to compete only in duathlons, comprised solely of biking and running.
Let's dig deeper into the gruesome stats. From the year 1540 through last week, there were 1,050 recorded shark attacks in U.S. waters, according to the University of Florida's International Shark Attack File. Roughly 65 percent of those were in Florida, with California and Hawaii accounting for another 10 percent each.
From 1948 -- when people first started thinking about writing this stuff down -- through last week, there were 522 alligator attacks in Florida, with a handful more occurring in Alabama, Georgia, Texas, South Carolina and Louisiana. One person was bitten by an alligator in North Carolina and, somehow, a lone fool in Arkansas managed to pull off the same feat.
The odds of being attacked by a shark are one in 11.5 million, according to the International Shark Attack File. But if you're in Florida, your chances of being chomped on by a gator are roughly 219 in 11.5 million.
So, now down to the real nitty gritty: Of those attacked by sharks and gators (not at the same time -- that would be statistically incomprehensible), which were more likely to buy the farm? Pass the great divide? Enter into eternal bliss and harmony? Or just die?
And Our Winner Is ...Since the shark people started keeping records 470 years ago, 50 people have been killed by sharks in U.S. waters. Since 1973, 22 people have been killed by gators in Florida alone.
Since 2000, sharks have sent eight Americans on to their great reward. In that same span, alligators have taken out a dozen, including a horrific stretch in May 2006 when three Floridians became gator-bait in four days.
So, which beast is the winner? You could make an argument either way, but statistics from several state wildlife departments and the International Shark Attack File give the nod to gators. About 4.3 percent of all alligator attacks result in death, compared to just 1.5 percent of shark attacks.
The real winner? Dogs killed 32 people last year in the U.S. alone, and have taken out 230 Americans since 2000.


























Live from Microsoft's New Generation Xbox event!
Xbox Reveal liveblog on Joystiq
Dozens Killed in Oklahoma Tornado; Death Toll to Rise
Watch: Kansas Meteorologist Seeks Shelter From Tornado
Xbox One architecture panel liveblog!
Justin Bieber Booed, Gets Standing Ovation at Billboard Music Awards
H&M's Plus-Size Model Jennie Runk Says She Chose To Gain Weight
Okla. Sheriff's Deputy Finds Dog Guarding Body Buried Under Destroyed Home
Two Pilots Fired After Brazilian Pop Star Takes Captain's Seat Mid-Flight







Comments:
Add a comment
Monday 09 August
By L.T. Hanlon
I think a bounty should be restored for alligators and crocodiles. We were doing just fine when their numbers were so low as to make alligator cowboy boots a rarity.
Reply
Sunday 08 August
By Natosha
There is a hunting season for gators and crocks. it only lasts a few days and its hard to get a permit..now do you even remember what happened the last time their was open season on them? the nutra over bred and tore up peoples property, crops, sheds, got into homes and terrorized people, ripping kitchens apart..worse than racoons ever could. yes they are very dangrous, you have to becareful in their element, they will eat you, but they serve a purpose. as far as which is more dangerous. they both are to me lol, I live on the ms gulf coast where both sharks and gators own the waters
Friday 06 August
By Greg
Well, let's not get into the fact that both of these animals are slaughtered by the thousands every year, for whatever reasons.
Reply
Friday 06 August
By Fred Pohl
I prefer the back yard swimming pool I'm too wary of these ponds I don't want to becomes a stastic of a alligator attack and I treat them as agressive Plus snapping turtles rattlers Cottonmouth Possibly pythons Thnaks but no thanks I dont do reptile
Reply
Friday 06 August
By New York State
What in God's name are Floridian's (or anyone) swimming in Ponds, Lakes or Canals for in the South??? Its a given you are just asking for trouble! Doesn’t everyone know that there are Croc’s/Gators wherever there is water and that they will most likely be in it, not to mention deadly snakes!? When swimming in the ocean it is at ones own risk, and chances of getting attacked by a Shark is very rare.
Reply
Sunday 08 August
By BlackHeart
New York State - That's my question! When my Parents and I were camping in Florida, the Park Ranger saw the CA license plate on the motor home and told us NOT TO LEAVE THE MOTOR HOME BETWEEN DUSK AND DAWN. The Ranger also pointed out, "Alligator Alley" and warned us to NEVER walk around that area. He said, "people walk in and they don't walk out".
Tuesday 24 August
By Bobby
Where are the stats on barracuda attacks? The most scared I've ever been was snorkeling in Key West when me & a young lady were approached by a school of a dozen or so. They swam directly underneath us with their teeth gleaming & hit a reef about 20' or so away & started circling. I looked around & she was long gone & I had to keep my wits about me. I swam away in very slow & ginger fashion toward our boat but they were definitely checking me out for the dinner menu. Their appearance is very intimidating even if they don't attack very often.
Sunday 08 August
By Bill
Don't worry about barracudas. They may make a run at you if you have something shiny or some jewelry on. Otherwise they will leave you alone because of your size. They are kinda sissy!
Sunday 08 August
By kelly
amen,i live in florida and if anyone is stupid enough to swim in any waterway down here that contains gators (and they all do) they deserve what they get....not to mention the idiots whose dogs are killed cause they let them swim in the ponds as well.
Sunday 08 August
By Gia
This article should take in account that we humans have encroached in their territory. Gators only become aggressive during mating season and if they lose their fear due to humans feeding them. Sharks(I live in the Shark bite capital)usually bite surfers out of mistaken identity as fisherman are fishing on the jetty alongside where the surfers are. Bottomline the chances of an attack are rare but you must remember we are in their territory. I'm a Floridian and nothing could keep me from the water.
Reply
Sunday 08 August
By Bill
Back in the day we used to snorkle through the weed patches in lakes, spearfishing gar. Of course, we waterskied in all the lakes. I would be a little more wary now. If I had a choice I would rather wrestle with a gator than a shark!
Reply
Sunday 08 August
By wesheajr
The people attacked by sharks and gators are in their territory. They are wild animals and humans are encroaching on their territory.
Personnally I give the most dangerous critter award to HUMANS. Humans can be found in all 50 States, water, dry land, etc. Humans are quite inventive in their methods of killing other humans.
Reply
Sunday 08 August
By Bill
Unfortunately, many people think humans are somehow above or superior to the 'animal' designation!
Sunday 08 August
By Karen
The moral of this story is DO NOT LIVE IN FLORIDA IF YOU PLAN ON GOING IN THE WATER! :-)
Reply
Sunday 08 August
By Bill
That's why I'm movin' to the mountains. It's easier to stare down a bear or wolf than to try and stare down a reptile or a fish!
Sunday 08 August
By Julie
Bill, bears will tear you up!!!
Sunday 08 August
By Bill
Not with the proper stare down technique. As a mammal they will focus more on your eyes. Reptiles and fish are too fast and skitterish to obtain eye contact.
Sunday 08 August
By Nicole
Bears rarely attack humans. I would rather camp (which I do) then swim with gators and sharks
Sunday 08 August
By Dick
There are a lot more people exposed to sharks at the beach swimming and surfing and out diving and fishing. There are nowhere as many people swimming and wading where gators live, mainly in canals, lakes and swamps.If there were you would see far more people killed by gators. This animal is very dangerous to humans today, especially children. When I was young and lived in Florida it was still open season on gators, when they saw you they tried to get away, not attack. It is ok to have a small population of them but there are far too many today, we to have open season on them to thin them down and to let them know humans are dangerous to them.
Reply
Sunday 08 August
By Shelly
then maybe we should have open season on humans cuz there is to many of them.